Which Plumber Putty Alternative Should You Use?

Plumber putty can sometimes be a nuisance to handle, and you may be looking for a more workable solution for installing drains, or other plumbing fixes. The main substitution comes from silicone-based products as you’ll see below. Silicon offers many advantages over standard plumbers putty. I won’t dive too deep into them here, but you can read more about it over here.

Today we are going to be looking at three alternative plumber putty products on the market right now, which is highly rated by plumbing professionals.

A quick overview of the top 3 plumber putty alternatives






GE Sealants & Adhesives 281 Advanced Silicone 2 Kitchen & Bath Sealant,...

GE Sealants & Adhesives 281 Advanced Silicone 2 Kitchen & Bath Sealant,...

  • 100% waterproof
  • Resistant to stains and mildew
  • Shrink and crack proof

Our Top Pick


Loctite 1716864 Tube Plumber and Marine Adhesive, 2.7 Ounces

Loctite 1716864 Tube Plumber and Marine Adhesive, 2.7 Ounces

  • Works on many surfaces
  • Great for sealing leaks
  • Dries transparent


Oatey 25605 Hercules 6-Ounce White Tube Plumber's Caulk

Oatey 25605 Hercules 6-Ounce White Tube Plumber's Caulk

  • Siliconized acrylic-latex
  • Will not crumble, resists shrinkage.
  • Extremely mildew-resistant, waterproof
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    1. LDR 502 7200 TUB CAULK

    Product no longer available. Use the product below instead

    GE Sealants & Adhesives 281 Advanced Silicone 2 Kitchen & Bath Sealant,…
    • 100% WATERPROOF: This 100% silicone formula offers ultimate protection from water damage, providing a…
    • 10-YEAR MOLD-FREE PRODUCT PROTECTION: Protects against stain-causing mold and mildew growth
    • 40% MORE FLEXIBILITY & 5X STRONGER ADHESION: Stays permanently flexible with a high-performing, durable…
    • 30-MINUTE WATER-READY: Ready for water exposure in as little as 30 minutes

    First on our list today is the LDR 502 7200 Tub Caulk, another alternative for plumber putty. It has been manufactured by LDR Industries.

    We can assure you that LDR Industries is a competitive standard for the best alternatives to plumber putties and they make high-end products that will work around your home.

    This caulk from LDR has a white finish after using it. The adhesive is made of silicon rubber, for easy usage and to hold tight. Its main goal is to seal cracks throughout the home easily and efficiently in record-setting time. The product comes in an 8-ounce tube, but it also can be hung up.

    Tubes that can be hung up are very beneficial when trying to tidy up your garage area. If you are a beginner to using a plumber putty alternative, this LDR product comes with an easy installation instruction manual, so you won’t do anything wrong.

    2. The Loctite 1716864 Tube Plumber and Marine Adhesive

    The Loctite 1716864 Tube Plumber and Marine Adhesive is the second product on our list today and is another best plumber putty alternative. Loctite is another manufacturer that we trust, especially because of the attention to detail within their products.

    This alternative to plumber putty comes in a 2.7-ounce tube for bonding aluminum, brick, ceramic, glass, leather, many plastics, rubber, steel, wood, and cardboard. It has can seal leaks around the home. If you have a tile that is loose, this adhesive has been built to secure it back in place.

    Outside of home care, it also can fix shoes and footwear, and mend your glasses back together in case of a break. What makes this product so great is that it dries transparent, making it easier to use it places, without it becoming an eye sore.

    It also has a drying method that takes its time, allowing you to re position something if it is not up to your satisfaction right away. This takes the pressure off that you have to do it perfectly on the first try. Once it is dry however, it is watertight and leak resistant, making it one of the best substitutes to plumber putty on the market today.

    Loctite 1716864 Tube Plumber and Marine Adhesive, 2.7 Ounces
    • Bonds aluminum, brick, cardboard, ceramic, fabric, fiberglass, glass, leather, most plastics, rubber,…
    • Great for sealing leaks, repairing tears, securing tiles, fixing footwear and mending glassware
    • Dries transparent for invisible repairs – dries gradually to allow time for repositioning
    • Seals watertight


    The last plumber putty alternative up for review is the Oatey 25605 Hercules 6-Ounce White Tube Plumber’s Caulk. Today we have decided, instead of focusing on just one huge plumber putty brand, to focus on three of the largest. This allows you to have a wide spectrum to choose from, especially since there are thousands of alternatives of plumber putties available on the market today.

    This last product has been developed by Oatey. If you know plumber putty, you know that Oatey is one of the best manufacturers for all things plumbing. They create high-end products that work, at a fraction of the cost of similar products. This is why they have made quite the name for themselves throughout the plumbing community.

    This alternative putty product is actually siliconized acrylic-latex caulk to be used instead of putty. It has a really smooth flow for consistent placement during a job. Inside the tube, this caulk will never harden and it does not crumble. When used, it resists shrinking by any means so you can feel good once a job is complete.

    The material is durable, flexible, resistant to any mildew, and waterproof—which is great for leaks. It is also at an incredibly affordable price. It comes in a compact 9-ounce tube that measures 6” by 1” by 1”.

    Oatey 25605 Hercules 6-Ounce White Tube Plumber’s Caulk
    • Siliconized acrylic-latex plumber’s caulk.
    • Flows easily, does not harden in tube or cartridge, will not crumble, resists shrinkage.
    • Flexible, durable, extremely mildew-resistant, waterproof.
    • Flows easily, does not harden in tube or cartridge, will not crumble, resists shrinkage


    The common theme between the three products with the con is that these tubes simply don’t come with enough product. They would benefit from having a larger tube to choose from so you can buy in bulk.

    That being said, the products themselves work outstandingly and are great to have around the home. They are going to fix cracks in places you never thought possible and provide a strong hold which is resistant to water. It is up to you to find out whether you want one that dries clear or one that dries with a white finish.

    Related Posts
    Like what you've read? Share it with your friends
    Share on facebook
    Share on twitter

    Leave a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Last update on 2020-07-10 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API